Don't let our relatively low rating dissuade you from getting this shingle if you are looking for a value. Sold exclusively at Menards this shingle offers a fair quality at a very reasonable price. They also have a little different cut lines that some of the more popular shingles which we find pleasing. It's a value architectural shingle that if installed perfect we'd expect 15-20 years out of as long as it didn't take too much weather. Little lighter, not quite as beefy but still just fine.