Shingle Comparison Chart

Yes, this table is HUGE – you probably cannot accurately view the entire table on many mobile platforms  or a smaller screen.  I have made a PDF version that fits on standard size paper that your can

Download Here - Asphalt Table

 

Additionally, a search function has been added to help you find what you are looking for.  ie Certainteed brings all those shingles, UL2218 will show you all impact resistant shingles, 130MPH will bring up all shingles with that wind rating from all manufacturers.

Manufacturer
Brand
Appearance
Stated Life(Years) Residential / Commercial 
Construction
Weight
Wind Resistance 
Algae Resistance
Impact Resistance
(Per Square)
CertainteedGrand ManorSlateLifetime / 50yrs2-Fiberglass Base425lbs110 MPH15yr StreakfighterUL2218 Class 2
CertainteedHighland SlateSlateLifetime / 50yrsSINGLE layer fiberglass240lbs110 MPH / 130MPH15yr StreakfighterUL2218 Class 4
CertainteedCentennial SlateSlateLifetime / 50yrs2-Fiberglass Base355lbs110 MPH15yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedCarriage HouseScallopedLifetime / 50yrs2-Fiberglass Base355lbs110 MPH15yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedPresidential Shake TLCedar ShakeLifetime / 50yrs3 piece Laminated Fiberglass480lbs110 MPH15yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedPresidential Shake Impact ResistantCedar ShakeLifetime / 50yrsFiberglass355lbs110MPH15yr StreakfighterUL2218 Class 4
CertainteedPresidential ShakeCedar ShakeLifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass355lbs110MPH15yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedPresidential SolarisWood Cedar ShakeLifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass355lbs110MPH15yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark TL Impact ResistantWood ShakesLifetime / 50yrs3 piece Laminated Fiberglass340lbs110MPH15yr StreakfighterUL2218 Class 4
CertainteedLandmark TL Wood ShakesLifetime / 50yrs3 piece Laminated Fiberglass340lbs110MPH / 130MPH15yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark PremiumArchitecturalLifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass300lbs90MPH / 130MPH10yr Streakfighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark SolarisArchitecturalLifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass300lbs90MPH / 130MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark Plus**Architectural40yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass280lbs80MPH / 130MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark IRArchitecturalLifetime2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass250lbs110MPH/ 130MPH10yr StreakFighterUL2218 Class 4
CertainteedLandmarkArchitectural30yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass240lbs70MPH / 110MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark ProArchitectural (Enhanced Colors)Lifetime2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass250lbs / 270lbs70MPH / 110MPH15yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark Woodscape PremiumArchitecturalLifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass300lbs90MPH / 130MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark Solaris PlatinumArchitectural (Solar Reflective Colors)Lifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass250lbs110MPH15yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark Solaris Gold IRArchitectural (Solar Reflective Colors)Lifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass250lbs110MPH15yr StreakFighterUL2218 Class 4
CertainteedLandmark Solaris GOLDArchitectural (Solar Reflective Colors)Lifetime / 50yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass250lbs110MPH15yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedLandmark Woodscape   Architectural30yrs2 Piece Laminated Fiberglass250lbs70MPH / 110MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedIndependenceModified DimensionalLifetime / 50yrs1 Fiberglass Base300lbs110 MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedHatterasOversized-Unique40yrsHeavy 1 Piece Fiberglass235lbs110 MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedXT-30 IR3-Tab30yrsFiberglass240lbs70MPH 10yr StreakFighterUL2218 Class 4
CertainteedXT-30  3-Tab30yrsFiberglass240lbs70MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated 
CertainteedXT-25 Metric3-Tab (Metric) 13 1/4 x 39 3/825yrsFiberglass220lbs60MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedXT-253-Tab25yrsFiberglass220lbs60MPH10yr StreakFighternot rated
CertainteedXT-20 **3-Tab20yrsFiberglass200lbs60MPHSelect Colors 10yrnot rated 
Owens CorningBerkshireSlate50yrsLaminated360lbs110MPH15yrsnot rated
Owens CorningWeatherguard HPArchitectural50yrsLaminated≈300lbs130MPH10yrsUL2218 Class 4
Owens CorningWoodMoorRustic Wood Shake50yrsLaminated450 lbs110MPH/ 130MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningWoodCrestRustic Wood Shake50yrsLaminated350lbs110MPH/ 130MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningDuration Premium CoolArchitectural (Solar Reflective Colors)LifetimeLaminated≈300lbs130MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningDuration Premium **ArchitecturalLifetimeLaminated≈300lbs130MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningDuration **Architectural30yrsLaminated≈260lbs110MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningTruDefinition Duration ArchitecturalLifetimeLaminated≈260lbs130MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningTruDefinition Duration Storm ArchitecturalLifetimeLaminated≈260lbs130MPH10yrsUL2218 Class 4
Owens CorningTruDefinition Duration Designer Colors ArchitecturalLifetimeLaminated≈260lbs130MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningOakridgeArchitectural30yrsLaminated≈215lbs70MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningSupreme AR3-Tab25yrsFiberglass≈180lbs60MPH10yrsnot rated
Owens CorningClassic **3-Tab20yrsFiberglass≈165lbs60MPHNONEnot rated
Gaf-ElkCamelotUnique - VariatedLifetimeFiberglass AsphaltOver 400lbs130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkGrand CanyonUnique - VariatedLifetimeFiberglass AsphaltOver 400lbs130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkCountry MansionSlateLifetimeFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkGrand SequoiaLarge - UniqueLifetimeFiberglass AsphaltOver400lbs130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkGrand SlateSlateLifetimeFiberglass AsphaltOver 400lbs130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkCapstoneUnique-RandomLifetimeFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkSlatelineSlateLifetimeFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkTimberline Prestique HD LifetimeArchitecturalLifetimeFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkTimberline Prestique 40yrArchitectural40yrsFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkTimberline Prestique 30yrArchitectural30yrsFiberglass Asphalt110MPHStainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkTimberline Natural ShadowArchitectural-Woodish30yrsFiberglass Asphalt100MPHStainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkTimberline Cool SeriesArchitecturalLifetimeFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkTimberline ArmorShield IIArchitecturalLifetimeFiberglass Asphalt130MPH *Stainguard LimitedUL2218 Class 4
Gaf-ElkMarquis Weathermax3-Tab30yrsFiberglass Asphalt80MPHStainguard Limitednot rated
Gaf-ElkRoyal Sovereign3-Tab25yrsFiberglass Asphalt60MPHStainguard Limitednot rated
TamkoHeritage VintageWood ShakesLifetime / 50yrsLaminated Fiberglass130MPH*10yrnot rated
TamkoHeritage 50Wood ShakesLifetime / 50yrsLaminated Fiberglass130MPH*10yrnot rated
TamkoHeritage 30Dimensional30yrsLaminated Fiberglass110MPH*10yrnot rated
TamkoHeritage XLWide Cut Dimensional40yrsLaminated Fiberglass110MPH*10yrnot rated
TamkoElite Glass Seal3-Tab25yrsFiberglass Asphalt110MPH*10yrnot rated
TamkoGlass Seal3-Tab20yrsFiberglass Asphalt60MOH___not rated
IKOArmourshakeWood ShakeLifetimeLaminated Fiberglass90MPH / 130MPH*Yes-refer to warrantynot rated
IKOCambridge 30 ARArchitectural30yrsLaminated Fiberglass70MPH / 110MPH*Yes-refer to warrantynot rated
IKOCambridge LTArchitecturalLifetimeLaminated Fiberglass90MPH / 130MPH*Yes-refer to warrantynot rated
IKOCrowne SlateSlateLifetimeLaminated Fiberglass90MPH / 130MPH*Yes-refer to warrantyUL2218 Class 4
IKOMarathon 25 AR3-Tab25yrsFiberglass Asphalt60MPHYes-refer to warrantynot rated
IKOMarathon Ultra AR3-Tab30yrsFiberglass Asphalt60MPHYes-refer to warrantynot rated
AtlasStormMaster SlateSlateLifetimeLaminated Fiberglass90MPH / 110MPH10yrsUL2218 Class 4
AtlasStormMaster LMArchitectural50yrsLaminated Fiberglass90MPH / 110MPH10yrsUL2218 Class 4
AtlasPinnacleWood Shake35yrs Laminated Fiberglass70MPH / 80MPH10yrsnot rated
AtlasChaletArchitectural30yrsLaminated Fiberglass60MPH / 80MPH10yrsnot rated
AtlasGlassMaster3-Tab25yrsFiberglass Asphalt60MPH10yrsnot rated
MalarkeyLegacyArchitectural50 Years LimitedSBS Modified Laminated Fiberglass275lbs110 MPH/ 130 MPH20 Years - ScotchgardUL2218 Class 4
MalarkeyNorthwest XLArchitectural40 Years LimitedLaminated Fiberglass260lbs80MPH/ 110 MPH20 Years - ScotchgardNA
MalarkeyHighlander CSArchitectural30 Years LimitedLaminated Fiberglass242lbs70MPH/ 110 MPH20 Years - ScotchgardNA
MalarkeyHurricane3-Tab35 Year LimitedSBS Modified Asphalt of Fiberglass Mat Base235lbs100MPH / 120MPH20 Years - ScotchgardUL2218 Class 4
MalarkeyThe Alaskan3-Tab35 Year LimitedSBS Modified Asphalt of Fiberglass Mat Base235lbs100MPH / 120MPHNAUL2218 Class 4
MalarkeyDura-Seal 253-Tab25 Year LimitedFiberglass Asphalt235lbs60MPHNANA
MalarkeyDura-Seal 203-Tab20 Year LimitedFiberglass Asphalt200lbs60MPHNANA
MalarkeyEcoasis PremiumArchitectural "Cool Roof"50 Years LimitedSBS Modified Laminated Fiberglass275lbs110 MPH/ 130 MPH20 Years - ScotchgardUL2218 Class 4
MalarkeyEcoasisArchitectural "Cool Roof"40 Years LimitedLaminated Fiberglass260lbs80MPH/ 110 MPHNANA


** = Discontinued Product Line  (May still be available B stock, or re-sellers)